Siding Contractor in Garden City, NY

Garden City was planned and built by Alexander Turney Stewart in the 1870s. Most of the village falls under the Garden City Historic District, which means the Architectural Review Board (HARB) has to approve exterior changes before a permit gets issued. Color, profile, reveal, trim width, corner detail. All of it.

This is not a rubber stamp. HARB has turned down siding applications that used the wrong reveal width or the wrong trim profile, even when the color was approved. The right contractor brings real material samples to the meeting, knows which products have been approved on other village homes in the last 5 years, and submits a clean package that does not get kicked back for missing documentation.

We have been through HARB 14 times. We know what they approve and what they send back.

Stewart-era Victorians (1870s-1900). The oldest homes in the village. Elaborate trim, shingle siding on gables, clapboard on main walls. These are almost always restored with real Western Red Cedar or Maibec Heritage to match the original profile. HARB is strict on these.

1920s-30s colonials. Center-hall, 2-story, shingle or clapboard originals. Many of these are candidates for James Hardie Artisan (the thicker Hardie profile) which gives the deeper shadow line HARB prefers. We have done 6 of these since 2020.

1950s-60s tract colonials (East Garden City and Stewart Manor side). Not in the historic district. These can use standard Hardie Plank or premium vinyl without HARB review, which gives the homeowner more material and color options.

Tudor revivals. Scattered through the village. Stucco on the lower, half-timber and shingle on the upper. Siding work on these is trickier because it often involves coordinating with a mason for the stucco repair. We have a mason we work with for these jobs.

HARB review timeline. The historic review board meets once a month. Submission deadline is 2 weeks before the meeting. If you miss a meeting, you wait 30 days. We plan every Garden City job around the HARB calendar so you do not lose a month.

Approved colors. HARB has a list of pre-approved colors and profiles. They are not the 80 vinyl colors in the CertainTeed catalog. We bring real samples to your walk-through that we know have been approved on other village homes, and we steer you away from anything that would get kicked back.

Trim profiles. 5/4 trim is the village standard. 1x4 trim (thinner) will often get flagged by HARB as not historically appropriate. Hardie Trim 5.5" and Maibec real-cedar trim pieces both meet the standard. We spec them by default on Garden City jobs.

Neighbors notice. Garden City neighbors are engaged. Parking matters. Dumpster location matters. Crew noise before 8am gets a phone call to the village hall. We brief every Garden City crew on the etiquette before the job starts.

Mature landscaping. Garden City yards have gardens that have been tended for 30-plus years. We tarp aggressively and we replace any bush we damage (we have replaced one in 14 years).

1928 colonial on Rockaway Avenue, 2024. Full Maibec Heritage Brown engineered cedar, including matching trim and gable shingle panels. Approved by HARB in one meeting. 2,600 sqft exterior. 13 working days. $58,000. The homeowner had a 1928 photo of the house in her attic and we matched the color and profile from the photo.

1931 Tudor revival on Cathedral Avenue, 2023. Partial reside (upper half-timber and shingle only, stucco retained). Real Western Red Cedar shake, natural color, clear-coat sealed. Coordinated with a mason for the lower stucco patch. 1,400 sqft of siding work. 10 working days. $38,500.

1960s colonial on Stewart Avenue, 2024. (East Garden City, outside historic district.) Full James Hardie Plank in Iron Gray with white HardieTrim 5.5" corners. 2,400 sqft exterior. 14 working days. $51,000.

Storm repair on Clinton Road, 2025. Tree limb took out a 20-foot section of gable shingle during a March wind event. Matched the existing Maibec from our shop stock (we order samples on every job and keep the leftovers). 2-day repair. $2,400, covered by insurance.

Garden City has its own village building department (not Nassau County, not a town). Siding permits are pulled at the village hall on Stewart Avenue. If your house is in the historic district, HARB approval is required before the permit is issued.

Typical timeline: 2-4 weeks for HARB approval, then 7-10 business days for the building permit itself after approval. Plan on 6 weeks from contract signing to start for historic district jobs.

We handle the HARB submission, the drawings, the color samples, and the in-person meeting if required. You sign the application, we do everything else.

Review 1: "Our 1928 colonial in Garden City needed new cedar and the historic district was going to be involved. Mike handled the HARB paperwork, brought three real Maibec samples to the meeting with the architectural committee, and had them approved in one session. The crew was quiet, respectful of our neighbors, and the finished house looks exactly like the 1928 photo we had in the attic." — Richard and Helen P., Garden City · Maibec Heritage Brown · 2024

Review 2: "We had been trying to reside our Tudor for 3 years but could not find a contractor who understood the half-timber-and-stucco combination. Mike came out, walked the house, and brought a mason to the second visit so we could coordinate the two trades. The finished job looks like the house did in 1931. Could not be happier." — Margaret H., Garden City · Real cedar shake · 2023